The Truth About AI Writing

2026-07-10 · Source: Artificial Intelligence in Plain English - Medium · Field: Technology & Digital — Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning, Emerging Technologies & Innovation, Marketing, Branding & Advertising · Depth: Fundamental Awareness, quick

Summary

The article, "The Truth About AI Writing," challenges the common polarized views on AI-generated content, asserting that its appropriateness depends entirely on the context and reader expectations. Author Andrew Best argues against the binary thinking that AI writing is either always acceptable (if disguised as human) or inherently bad. Instead, he proposes a spectrum where some content, like Ikea assembly instructions, can be 100% AI-written as long as it's clear and effective, because the reader's primary concern is utility, not authorship. Conversely, content requiring deep human connection, empathy, or personal experience, such as a true survival story, demands human authorship, as the emotional impact and authenticity are paramount. This perspective shifts the conversation from "who wrote it" to "what is the purpose and desired impact of the writing."

Key takeaway

For content strategists and marketing professionals evaluating AI writing tools, you should move beyond the simple "AI or human" debate. Instead, assess your content's core purpose: if it's purely functional, like instructions, prioritize clarity and efficiency, making AI a viable option. However, for narratives requiring genuine human connection or emotional depth, ensure human authorship to maintain authenticity and reader engagement. This approach optimizes resource allocation while preserving content integrity.

Key insights

The suitability of AI writing depends on content purpose and reader expectations, not just authorship.

Principles

• Utility-focused content tolerates AI.
• Emotion-driven content requires human.
• Context dictates AI writing value.

In practice

• Evaluate content purpose before using AI.
• Prioritize clarity for instructional text.
• Reserve human touch for emotional narratives.

Topics

• AI Writing
• Content Strategy
• Generative AI
• Content Authenticity
• Writing Ethics
• Human-AI Collaboration

Best for: Product Manager, Marketing Professional, AI Product Manager, Consultant

Related on AIssential

• More than half of new articles on the internet are being written by AI — Over half of new online articles are AI-generated, shifting content creation towards formulaic, low-stakes writing.
• Claude Writes Better Than Me. Am I Even a Writer Anymore? — Human writing's value stems from unique lived experience, not just technical efficiency, a domain AI cannot replicate.
• Our Rules for AI Writing — Ethical AI writing involves using AI as an assistant, not a ghostwriter, to preserve human authorship, learning, and accountability.
• Is this blog written by AI? — The author distinguishes between AI's role in human-facing text (no) and code (yes), prioritizing human connection in writing.
• It’s time for AI to worry about humans — Human storytellers are increasingly vital for startups to differentiate their brands amidst the proliferation of generic AI-generated content.
• ‘Obvious markers of AI’: doubts raised over winner of short story prize — The definitive detection of AI-generated creative work remains elusive, posing challenges for literary awards and publishers.

See Counsel's argued verdicts on the open AI decisions leaders are weighing →

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by Artificial Intelligence in Plain English - Medium.