Our Rules for AI Writing

2025-08-05 · Source: AI Policy Perspectives · Field: Media & Entertainment — Content Creation & Production, Publishing & Journalism · Depth: Fundamental Awareness, quick

Summary

The article "Our Rules for AI Writing" by Tom Rachman & Conor Griffin outlines five principles for ethical AI usage in writing. It emphasizes that while AI is useful for learning, critique, and research, it should never be used to knowingly publish AI-generated text under a human byline. The "Embarrassment Rule" warns that future AI detection will expose current clandestine usage, citing "post-2022 fabrications" already being identified. The "Intern Rule" suggests treating AI contributions like a human assistant's, acceptable for process tasks like explaining subjects, summarizing articles, brainstorming, or proofreading, but not for supplying all ideas or rewriting. The "Ventriloquist's Rule" highlights that relying on AI for writing hinders personal learning and wisdom development. The "No-Dumping Rule" discourages outsourcing replies to chatbots, especially when a personal opinion is sought. Finally, the "Byline Rule" asserts that a byline is an oath, implying deception if the named author did not primarily write the text, distinguishing between types of writing where authorship matters versus those where it doesn't.

Key takeaway

For professional writers and content creators integrating AI into their workflow, recognize that your byline is an implicit promise of human authorship. Avoid using AI to generate final text, as future detection is likely and it diminishes your own learning. Instead, leverage AI as a research assistant for summarizing, brainstorming, or proofreading, but always ensure the core ideas and final expression are authentically yours to maintain credibility and foster personal expertise.

Key insights

Ethical AI writing involves using AI as an assistant, not a ghostwriter, to preserve human authorship, learning, and accountability.

Principles

• Assume AI usage will be discovered.
• Treat AI contributions as a human assistant's.
• Personal writing fosters deeper understanding.

In practice

• Use AI to explain subjects or summarize articles.
• Employ AI for brainstorming personal ideas.
• Utilize AI for proofreading your text.

Topics

• AI Ethics
• Content Creation
• Authorship
• AI Detection
• Writing Workflow
• Professional Standards

Best for: Marketing Professional, Tech Journalist, AI Ethicist

Related on AIssential

• There is only a smart way to use ai as a writer: — Smart writers use AI for research, brainstorming, and editing, but not for generating prose.
• More than half of new articles on the internet are being written by AI — Over half of new online articles are AI-generated, shifting content creation towards formulaic, low-stakes writing.
• Is this blog written by AI? — The author distinguishes between AI's role in human-facing text (no) and code (yes), prioritizing human connection in writing.
• Claude Writes Better Than Me. Am I Even a Writer Anymore? — Human writing's value stems from unique lived experience, not just technical efficiency, a domain AI cannot replicate.
• 33 Tiny Habits That Make Your Writing Sound Like a Robot — AI-assisted writing often develops subtle, repetitive "tells" that betray its machine origin, which can be identified and corrected.
• ‘Obvious markers of AI’: doubts raised over winner of short story prize — The definitive detection of AI-generated creative work remains elusive, posing challenges for literary awards and publishers.

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by AI Policy Perspectives.