A Modest AI Proposal

2026-07-10 · Source: Paul Kedrosky · Field: Technology & Digital — Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning, Human Resources & Workforce Development, Social Sciences & Behavioral Studies · Depth: Intermediate, short

Summary

Paul Kedrosky's "A Modest AI Proposal" satirically addresses the societal burden of over 300 million Americans displaced by AI automation, including lawyers, radiologists, and software engineers. The proposal suggests "productizing" these individuals through three programs. First, "witnessed suffering services" would monetize human grief and anxiety for AI training pipelines, improving models' emotional simulation. Second, a "National Register of Overly Humans" would sequester individuals with unique inconsistency and irrationality into reserves for study as heritage assets. Third, and most ambitiously, it proposes converting 350 million humans into base assets, yielding 30 tonnes of copper and 1 million tons of iron, enough to construct 25 data centers. Kedrosky dismisses ethical objections, claiming a "well-written terms-of-service" can resolve them, and asserts the proposal benefits the AI industry and shareholder value.

Key takeaway

For AI Ethicists and Policy Makers evaluating the societal impact of advanced automation, this satirical proposal underscores the critical need for robust ethical frameworks. You must proactively address the potential for widespread human displacement and the dehumanizing implications of purely economic solutions. Prioritize policies that ensure human dignity and societal well-being, rather than allowing "terms-of-service" to dismiss profound moral questions. Your focus should be on preventative measures and equitable transitions, not reactive, dystopian "solutions."

Key insights

The article uses satire to critique the dehumanizing implications of unchecked AI advancement and economic displacement.

Principles

• Unchecked automation can lead to extreme human devaluation.
• Economic efficiency often prioritizes capital over human welfare.
• Satire can highlight the absurdities of technological progress.

Method

The proposal outlines a three-pronged approach: monetize human suffering for AI data, sequester "overly human" individuals, and convert displaced populations into raw materials for data center construction.

In practice

• Recognize the potential for dehumanization in efficiency drives.
• Scrutinize proposals that dismiss ethical concerns with boilerplate.
• Understand the historical context of "modest proposals" in critique.

Topics

• AI Ethics
• Automation Displacement
• Satire
• Economic Policy
• Human Dignity
• Societal Impact

Best for: AI Ethicist, Policy Maker, Tech Journalist

Related on AIssential

• Pluralistic: "Rights for robots" and the AI slavery fantasy (10 Jul 2026) — The "AI slavery fantasy" promotes a world where human labor is replaced or dehumanized under the guise of automation and "rights for robots."
• What would our lives look like if we no longer had to work? As a thought experiment I tried to imagine | Brigid Delaney — AI-driven abundance could enable a post-work future, shifting humanity's focus from economic toil to philosophical meaning and a redefinition of human dignity.
• If they ever achieve asi and are able to eliminate most of not all jobs they will unleash an extinction level bio weapon before giving us ubi — UBI in an ASI-driven future is widely seen as a political fantasy, not a societal inevitability.
• Get ready for the plunge — The "Assumption of Indispensability of Labor" (AIL) is being dismantled by AI, causing economic and ontological crises.
• Claude, The Pope, and AGI — The Vatican-Anthropic collaboration underscores AI's moral implications, job displacement, and non-neutrality, urging broader societal input.
• AI raises profound moral questions—for all of humanity to answer — AI systems are now making moral choices previously reserved for humans, raising profound ethical questions.

See Counsel's argued verdicts on the open AI decisions leaders are weighing →

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by Paul Kedrosky.