HAJJv2-CrowdCount: Zero-Shot Benchmark for Dense Crowd Counting
Summary
HAJJv2-CrowdCount is a new per-second human-annotated crowd counting benchmark for the HAJJv2 dataset, designed to address the challenges of dense crowd footage from steep, near-vertical camera angles with extensive occlusion and over a thousand people per frame. This benchmark evaluates three zero-shot counting paradigms: YOLO-World (an open-vocabulary detector), APGCC (a point-based counter), and SAM3Count (a promptable segmentation-based counter). SAM3Count achieved the lowest overall mean absolute error (MAE 70.4, 95% CI 56.0-86.1), outperforming YOLO-World (92.0) and APGCC (152.9). However, in the densest frames, crucial for Hajj crowd management, this order reverses; detection- and segmentation-based counters degrade sharply (MAE exceeding 300), while the point-based APGCC degrades more gracefully (MAE 114.9). The annotations are publicly released.
Key takeaway
For Computer Vision Engineers developing crowd management systems, especially in high-density, occluded environments like Hajj, your model selection should prioritize performance on the densest frames over overall mean absolute error. While segmentation-based models might show lower average MAE, point-based counters like APGCC demonstrate superior robustness and reliability when counts are most critically needed in extremely dense scenes, preventing sharp degradation.
Key insights
Zero-shot crowd counting performance in dense, occluded scenes reverses model efficacy compared to overall metrics.
Principles
- Dense crowd counting requires specialized model robustness.
- Overall MAE may not reflect real-world deployment needs.
Method
The method involves annotating per-second crowd counts for HAJJv2 test videos and benchmarking zero-shot models (YOLO-World, APGCC, SAM3Count) against these annotations, specifically analyzing performance in dense frames.
In practice
- Evaluate crowd counting models on scene density subsets.
- Consider point-based counters for extremely dense environments.
Topics
- Crowd Counting
- Zero-Shot Learning
- HAJJv2-CrowdCount
- Dense Scenes
- Computer Vision Benchmarks
- APGCC
Best for: Research Scientist, AI Scientist, Machine Learning Engineer, Computer Vision Engineer
Related on AIssential
Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition.