Bullet Points: digital futures' past
Summary
The article critiques a recurring error in tech futurism: the tendency to predict new eras of abundance while overlooking the emergent scarcities that ultimately define societal and economic structures. Using Kevin Kelly's 2005 essay "We Are the Web" as a primary example, the author highlights how Kelly accurately foresaw a 2015 world of content abundance—with 175,000 books and 30,000 music albums released, and 14 million blogs launched—but failed to anticipate attention becoming the dominant scarce resource, leading to the attention economy and influencer culture. This analytical framework is then applied to the current "AI future," where companies like SpaceX, valued at \$2.2 trillion with negative \$4 billion in revenues, promise intelligence abundance. The author argues these narratives ignore the critical question of what new scarcities will arise, concluding that the finance industry has largely consumed the software industry, shaping Silicon Valley's strategic behavior.
Key takeaway
For investors or analysts evaluating the "AI future," you should critically assess claims of intelligence abundance. Do not simply accept utopian narratives; instead, identify what new scarcities will inevitably emerge from such abundance. Your due diligence must include asking AI companies how they plan to organize around these scarcities, who will profit, and who will be made vulnerable. This approach helps you avoid being misled by superficial promises and better understand true market dynamics.
Key insights
Tech futurists frequently misinterpret future impact by focusing on new abundance, overlooking the critical emergent scarcities.
Principles
- Focus on emergent scarcity, not just abundance.
- New abundance always creates new scarcity.
- Finance now defines the software industry.
Method
To analyze tech predictions, identify the promised abundance, then critically ask what new scarcity will emerge and how society will organize around it.
In practice
- Apply a "scarcity lens" to AI predictions.
- Question AI companies on emergent scarcities.
- Understand finance's influence on tech strategy.
Topics
- Tech Futurism
- Scarcity Economics
- Attention Economy
- AI Investment
- Financialization
- Digital Culture
Best for: Investor, Consultant, Tech Journalist
Related on AIssential
See Counsel's argued verdicts on the open AI decisions leaders are weighing →
Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by The Future, Now and Then.