I retested Apple AirTags after 5 years - how they compare to Bluetooth tracker rivals

2026-04-17 · Source: News and Advice on the World's Latest Innovations | ZDNET · Field: Technology & Digital — Internet of Things (IoT) & Connected Devices, Emerging Technologies & Innovation · Depth: Fundamental Awareness, medium

Summary

ZDNET's Adrian Kingsley-Hughes conducted a comparative test of item tracking tags, including Apple AirTags and several third-party alternatives like Chipolo Card, KeySmart SmartCard, and LuLuLook AirCard Pro. The experiment involved scattering these tags in a motel parking lot and activating "lost mode" to assess their detection range, precision finding, and reliability across Apple's Find My and Google's Find Hub networks. The second-generation AirTag, featuring upgraded Bluetooth, a louder speaker, and a U2 chip for extended precision finding and Apple Watch support, demonstrated superior performance in detection range and precision. While third-party tags on the Apple Find My network performed similarly well for general location tracking, they lacked precision finding. All tested tags for Android devices consistently pinged their locations multiple times daily, and their loud beepers aided recovery even amidst road traffic noise.

Key takeaway

For individuals seeking to prevent loss or recover misplaced items, investing in a tracking tag is highly effective. While Apple AirTags offer the most reliable and precise tracking experience, especially with their Ultra-Wideband technology, third-party tags are a viable option for both iOS and Android users, dramatically increasing the likelihood of recovering lost possessions. Consider your device ecosystem and desired precision when selecting a tag.

Key insights

Apple AirTags offer superior precision and reliability for item tracking compared to third-party alternatives.

Principles

• UWB enhances tracking precision and security.
• Any tracking tag significantly improves item recovery.

Method

Test tracking tags by scattering them in a public area, activating lost mode, and monitoring detection frequency and precision across different mobile ecosystems.

In practice

• Use AirTags for maximum precision on iOS.
• Employ third-party tags for broad compatibility.
• Utilize "lost mode" for automated location updates.

Topics

• Apple AirTags
• Bluetooth Trackers
• Ultra-Wideband Technology
• Apple Find My Network
• Google Find Hub

Best for: General Interest, Tech Journalist

Related on AIssential

• Apple’s first-gen AirTags are still worth buying now that they’re $16 apiece — First-gen Apple AirTags offer precise tracking and robust features at a discounted price as second-gen models emerge.
• The best earbuds of 2026: Expert tested and reviewed — ZDNET's 2026 review highlights the Apple AirPods Pro 3 as the "best overall earbuds," offering significant upgrades like in-ear heart rate monitoring, IP57 durability, a U2 ultrawideband chip, and sea…
• PSA: Don't replace your AirTag battery with a rechargeable one - or else this happens — Do not use LIR2032 rechargeable batteries in devices designed for CR2032 disposable cells due to voltage and capacity differences.
• Wear OS 7 helps your smartwatch keep up with you — Wear OS 7 enhances smartwatch utility with real-time updates, device control, AI-driven personalization, and improved battery life.
• Enhanced License Plate Tracking — ALPRs are evolving to track individuals through Bluetooth device identifiers, significantly expanding surveillance beyond vehicles.
• Snap’s Specs look good on nobody — Snap's \$2,195 Specs offer advanced AR capabilities but face significant user adoption hurdles due to their bulky design.

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by News and Advice on the World's Latest Innovations | ZDNET.