Rewriting Bun in Rust
Summary
Jarred Sumner successfully rewrote the Bun JavaScript runtime from Zig to Rust, a project he had been discussing since May 9th. This ambitious undertaking was primarily motivated by persistent memory management bugs, such as use-after-free and double-free errors, which Rust's inherent safety features and RAII-like automatic cleanup mechanisms effectively mitigate. A key enabler for this massive rewrite was an "agent harness" that leveraged Bun's existing TypeScript test suite as a conformance suite. This harness automated a significant portion of the initial porting process using an earlier version of the Claude LLM, requiring 5.9 billion uncached input tokens and costing an estimated \$165,000 at API pricing. The new Rust implementation, live in Claude Code since June 17th (v2.1.181), demonstrated a 10% faster startup on Linux, validating the approach and showcasing how frontier models can facilitate large-scale software rewrites.
Key takeaway
For AI Architects evaluating large-scale system rewrites, this case demonstrates that modern frontier models fundamentally alter the feasibility equation. You should now consider LLM-powered agent harnesses, especially when a comprehensive, language-independent test suite exists, to automate significant portions of the porting effort. This approach can mitigate the traditional risks and costs associated with ground-up rewrites, enabling projects previously deemed impractical.
Key insights
LLM-powered agent harnesses can enable large-scale software rewrites, overcoming traditional barriers to such projects.
Principles
- Language choice is no longer a one-way decision.
- Robust test suites enable agentic code generation.
- Fix the generation process, not just the code.
Method
Automate initial code porting using an LLM-powered agent harness with a language-independent conformance test suite, then iteratively refine the generation process.
In practice
- Use Rust for memory-safe system-level programming.
- Develop comprehensive test suites for agentic development.
- Consider LLMs for large-scale code refactoring.
Topics
- Bun JavaScript Runtime
- Rust Programming Language
- LLM Code Generation
- Agentic Engineering
- Software Rewrites
- Memory Safety
Best for: CTO, VP of Engineering/Data, Director of AI/ML, Software Engineer, AI Engineer, AI Architect
Related on AIssential
Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by Simon Willison's Weblog.