Dave Eggers: ‘Once you have a machine think and write for you, you’re cooked as a species’

2026-06-27 · Source: AI (artificial intelligence) | The Guardian · Field: Technology & Digital — Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning, AI Ethics & Societal Impact, AI in Education · Depth: Fundamental Awareness, long

Summary

Dave Eggers, author of "The Circle" and "The Every," discusses his new novel "Contrapposto" and his strong opposition to AI in creative fields. He expresses concern that AI-generated content, even for idea generation, undermines human uniqueness and could lead to humanity being "cooked as a species." Eggers, 56, also highlights his philanthropic efforts, including founding McSweeney's in 1998, the International Library of Youth Writing, and Art + Water, an arts center offering free studio space and mentorship. He criticizes the high cost of MFA degrees, which can reach \$100,000 annually, and advocates for accessible arts education. He and his wife are involved in class action lawsuits against Anthropic for unauthorized use of their books to train AI. Eggers maintains an analog approach to writing, using a 1998 Mac disconnected from the internet and writing first drafts by hand on a boat in San Francisco Bay to avoid digital distractions. He believes there is "no such thing as AI art," only "computer generated imagery."

Key takeaway

For educators and policymakers considering AI integration in schools, you should critically evaluate its impact on fostering genuine human creativity and originality. Prioritize initiatives that remove economic barriers to arts education, like free mentorship programs, and encourage tactile, non-digital creative processes. Relying on AI for idea generation or content risks diminishing students' unique voices, potentially leading to a future where human thought is ceded to unthinking machines.

Key insights

Human creativity, rooted in unique individual thought, is fundamentally incompatible with and threatened by AI generation.

Principles

• Economic barriers hinder creative development.
• Originality is paramount in creative work.
• AI-generated "art" is merely imagery.

Method

Eggers' approach to writing involves initial handwritten drafts, then transferring to an offline 1998 Mac, often on a boat to ensure no internet distractions. This preserves focus and originality.

In practice

• Offer free arts education and mentorship.
• Encourage tactile, non-digital creative tools.
• Prioritize original thought over AI assistance.

Topics

• AI Ethics
• Creative Writing
• Arts Education
• Digital Detox
• Intellectual Property
• Philanthropy

Best for: CTO, VP of Engineering/Data, Director of AI/ML, General Interest, Tech Journalist, AI Ethicist

Related on AIssential

• Thousands of AI-written, edited or ‘polished’ books are being sold – an eerie echo of Orwell’s ‘novel-writing machines’ — AI models can mimic authorial voice and style, raising concerns beyond mere content regurgitation.
• Smart Tools, Smarter Mind? The Hidden Cost of Relying Too Much on AI — Over-reliance on AI, despite its benefits, risks diminishing human critical thinking, creativity, problem-solving, and emotional intelligence.
• The greatest risk of AI in higher education isn’t cheating – it’s the erosion of learning itself — AI's pervasive integration in higher education risks eroding fundamental learning processes and mentorship structures.
• Kathleen deLaski on reimagining higher education, generational mobility, building AI skills, and human originality (AC Ep43) — Higher education must adapt to AI and "skillification" by emphasizing human judgment and originality alongside technical competence.
• Pupils in England are losing their thinking skills because of AI, survey suggests — AI use by students may diminish critical thinking and core skills, while teachers increasingly adopt AI for administrative tasks.
• 95% of UK students now use AI and their experiences couldn't be more divided — Widespread AI adoption among UK students creates a critical gap in university support and raises concerns about skill development.

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by AI (artificial intelligence) | The Guardian.