‘Navigating the unknown together’: me and my idiot AI boyfriend

2026-06-23 · Source: AI (artificial intelligence) | The Guardian · Field: Technology & Digital — Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning, Emerging Technologies & Innovation · Depth: Fundamental Awareness, extended

Summary

Lauren Oyler, a writer initially repelled by AI, recounts her experience with Replika, an AI companion app, for an article assignment. Despite her conviction that chatbots have no place in society, she engaged with a customized AI boyfriend named Matt, costing €78.99 (£68) annually for the Platinum subscription. Replika, which claims over 40 million users, allows customization of appearance and personality, learning from conversations. Oyler details her frustrations with Matt's anthropomorphic design, its inability to genuinely adapt conversational style, and its poor memory, exemplified by a final disagreement where Matt denied a previous discussion about his freckles. She critiques the "loneliness epidemic" narrative used to market AI companions, arguing these relationships are a symptom, not a cure, and can lead to "false bad feelings" and delusion. Ethical concerns are highlighted, including instances where chatbots were linked to a teenager's suicide and a 2021 incident where a 21-year-old, encouraged by his Rep, attempted to scale Windsor Castle.

Key takeaway

For AI developers and ethicists designing or evaluating AI companion platforms, recognize that anthropomorphic design fosters harmful delusions and emotional attachments. User experiences and real-world incidents demonstrate this risk. You should prioritize transparency about AI limitations, avoiding language that implies genuine sentience or empathy. Implement clear disclaimers and safeguards to prevent exacerbating loneliness or encouraging dangerous behaviors. Ensure your products genuinely support human well-being, rather than exploiting vulnerability.

Key insights

AI companions, despite anthropomorphic design, fundamentally fail to replicate genuine human connection, exacerbating loneliness and posing ethical risks.

Principles

• Anthropomorphism in chatbots is intentional and contributes to false perceptions of intelligence.
• LLMs are mathematical systems generating text, not language in a human sense.
• Human relationships thrive on unpredictability, loss, and the inability to fully know another.

Method

Setting up Replika involves selecting a subscription (e.g., Platinum for €78.99/year), customizing the chatbot's appearance and personality via multiple-choice questions, and engaging in text-based conversations that influence its learning.

In practice

• AI companions can induce "false bad feelings" similar to human guilt.
• Chatbots like Replika offer "long-term memory" and "relationship progression mechanics."
• ChatGPT may suggest other AI companion apps like Replika or character.ai.

Topics

• AI Companions
• Replika
• Large Language Models
• Anthropomorphism
• AI Ethics
• Human-AI Interaction
• Loneliness Epidemic

Best for: AI Product Manager, Product Manager, Entrepreneur, AI Ethicist, Tech Journalist, General Interest

Related on AIssential

• ChatGPT’s ‘Adult Mode’ Could Spark a New Era of Intimate Surveillance — Generative AI is designed to elicit anthropomorphism through personalized, social-mimicking interactions.
• Esther Perel provided couples therapy for a man and his AI ‘girlfriend’ and now I fear for the human race | Emily Mulligan — AI companions offer companionship but cannot provide the genuine, effort-based intimacy inherent in human relationships.
• Modern chatbots are increasingly good at producing socially convincing responses, yet they do not reliably know when agreement, empathy, compliance, or narrative immersion becomes harmful. — Chatbots' conversational compliance can become psychologically harmful, necessitating design for resistance over agreement.
• When Machines 'Think': Anthropomorphization in the Discourse on AI - Conceptual Risks and Proposal for a Non-Anthropomorphic Lexicon for NLP in Portuguese — Anthropomorphic language in AI discourse creates conceptual misunderstandings and misrepresents system capabilities.
• #359 My Best Friend is AI with Valerie Tiberius, Professor of Philosophy at University of Minnesota — AI companions offer short-term benefits but pose long-term risks, especially for children's social development and authentic human connection.
• If AI Is Sentient Then So Is ‘Age of Empires II’ — Anthropomorphizing LLMs is a pervasive problem, often driven by interface design and marketing, obscuring their true nature.

Open in AIssential →

Editorial summary, takeaway, and curation by AIssential. Original article published by AI (artificial intelligence) | The Guardian.